Asked by: Will Menyfield

How do you respond to an editor review?

Ten simple rules for writing a response to reviewers

1. Rule 1: Provide an overview, then quote the full set of reviews.
2. Rule 2: Be polite and respectful of all reviewers.
3. Rule 3: Accept the blame.
4. Rule 4: Make the response self-contained.
5. Rule 5: Respond to every point raised by the reviewer.

What does editorial feedback mean?

An editorial review involves a writing and editing expert dedicating time to evaluate the work. The reviewers are often experts in that specific niche and can let readers know how the work compares to similar pieces.

How do you respond to an editor?

Dear editor, We thank you very much for the comments and suggestions. The comments and suggestions are valuable and very helpful for revising and improving our manuscript. We have made revisions according to the referees’ comments and suggestions, as described in the authors’ response.

How do you write a comment for a paper review?

Avoid overly negative wording or personal comments, point out the main strengths of the manuscript as well as its weaknesses, and suggest specific ways to fix the problems you identify. Also, avoid making overly brief and direct comments, as these can give your report an unfriendly tone.

How do you write a response letter for feedback?

12 Tips for Writing a Thank You Letter for Customer Feedback

1. Review the feedback carefully before writing a response. …
2. Address customers by their first name. …
3. Thank customers twice. …
4. Apologize for the inconvenience, if necessary. …
5. Show them some empathy. …
6. Give a brief explanation based on their feedback.

How do you respond to a reviewer comment example?

How to reply to peer review comments when submitting papers for publication

1. We thank the reviewer for pointing this out. We have revised.
2. We have removed.
3. We agree and have updated.
4. We have fixed the error.
5. This observation is correct. We have changed.
6. We have made the change. The new sentence reads as follows.

What does an editorial review look like?

An editorial book review is an unbiased, reader-focused review of your published or soon-to-be published book, often used by publishers on marketing material like book covers, posters, and on the “editorial reviews” section on their Amazon sales page.

What is the difference between editorial review and peer review?

For a good dissertation, both editing and peer review are advantageous. Editing rectifies the structure of your dissertation whereas peer review gives you an extensive analysis of your dissertation. However, peer review includes editing and proofreading in itself.

How do you review something?

Top tips for writing a review

1. 1 Read, watch, or listen to the work more than once. …
2. 2 Provide essential information. …
3. 3 Understand your audience. …
4. 4 Take a stand. …
5. 5 Explain how you’re judging the work. …
6. 6 Introduce evidence to support your criteria. …
7. 7 Know the conventions of the genre. …
8. 8 Compare and contrast.

How do you comment on a manuscript?

Number your points and refer to page and line numbers in the manuscript when making specific comments. If you have been asked to only comment on specific parts or aspects of the manuscript, you should indicate clearly which these are. Treat the author’s work the way you would like your own to be treated.

How do you give good feedback to peer review?

How to Give Constructive Peer Feedback

1. Prepare. Before you even say a word to your coworker, identify the goals of your conversation. …
2. Avoid the “Feedback Sandwich” …
3. Do It Early but Don’t Catch Them Off Guard. …
4. Don’t Attack or Insult. …
5. Be Clear. …
6. Be Specific. …
7. Don’t Tell Them They’re Wrong. …
8. Use Non-Judgmental Language.

How do you comment on a research proposal?

Present a fact or a claim from a named (or linked) source and explain why it is relevant for the proposed research. Explain how it casts doubt or increases our confidence in a point made by the author. Your additional ideas. Could this or a closely related question be answered in a different way (specify)?

How do you comment on a project?

How to Write an Effective Comment

1. Note the project number and address.
2. Review the project file and plans.
3. Consider criteria (listed above) relevant to the application.
4. Explain your interest in the project.
5. Provide additional site or context information that you think is important.

How do I give a dissertation feedback?

Tips For Responding to Someone Else’s Writing

1. Say something positive. …
2. Talk about your responses while reading the work. …
3. Critique the writing, not the writer. …
4. Be specific. …
5. Prioritize your comments. …
6. Summarize comments in a paragraph or two. …
7. Golden Rule.

How is a Masters dissertation marked?

Typically dissertations are blind double marked. So that each marker judges the work independently and only then discusses with a colleague, the definitive mark to be awarded.

What is a good dissertation mark?

60-69% (Good) Structure and organisation is good but may have some omissions. Knowledge displayed is good and shows independent thought but may have some omissions. Application of knowledge and understanding is good and shows independent thought but may have some omissions.

What is a good mark for a Masters dissertation?

Often, to achieve a certain classification, you are required to achieve that mark as minimum on your dissertation, for example, for a merit, your dissertation needs to score 60 or above, and for a distinction, 70 or above.

What is the pass mark for a dissertation?

50

The Pass Mark for the dissertation is 50. A student failing to achieve the Pass Mark may submit a revised dissertation on the same subject on one occasion only.

Is 60% a first?

First-Class Honours (First or 1st) (70% and above) Upper Second-Class Honours (2:1, 2. i) (60-70%)

How do you get a 2.1 in a dissertation?

5 Ways To Improve Your Dissertation From a 2:2 (C) to a 2:1 (B)…

1. Proofread Carefully. It is almost impossible to achieve a 2:1 if your work is marked by significant errors in spelling, punctuation or grammar. …
2. Be Precise and Be Concise. …
3. Demonstrate Extensive Research. …
4. Develop a Consistent Angle. …
5. Prepare Early Drafts.