Should I have some restraint when submitting to the more prestigious journals?
Asked by: Sara Crow
What are two important considerations when selecting a journal for submission?
How to choose journals for submitting your paper
- Is there a match between the subject of your article and the journal’s aim and scope? …
- What is the readership and target audience? …
- Is the journal highly visible? …
- What is the journal’s turnaround time?
Why is it unethical to submit to multiple journals?
This is known as simultaneous or concurrent submission and is considered as an unethical practice. This is because it leads to a waste of academic and scientific resources as two or more journals would spend time and money on carrying out the same tasks.
What percentage of manuscripts is rejected from prestigious academic journals?
Most top journals have almost 80% rejection rates.
Which are the factors should be considered in choosing reputable journal?
Factors Influencing the Choice of a Journal
- Journals subject coverage and types of papers published.
- Manuscript length, number of tables, figures and authors, etc.
- Journal’s turnaround time.
- Publication charges (including page or colour charges)
What do you need to consider when choosing a journal for your article Paper Submission?
Criteria for Evaluating a Journal
- Scientific Rigor. A key indicator of journal quality is the scientific rigor of the publications published in the journal. …
- Editorial Quality. …
- Peer Review Process. …
- Ethics. …
- Editorial Board Members. …
- Journal Reputation/Business Model. …
- Author Rights and Copyright. …
- Indexing Status.
What are considered top journals?
Top journals are generally considered to be those in the upper quartile (Q1) of SJR scores. Using the SCImago journal ranking tool, you can compare journals within a comprehensive list of professional scientific journals or narrow your search down to a specific field or discipline.
What happens if you submit to two journals?
If you submit the same paper to two different journals, soon or later the editors, reviewers and editor-in-chief will know it and then, probably your name will be banned from many journals: no more papers will be considered for publication.
Should I send my manuscript to multiple publishers?
I agree, best to focus on one publisher with your submission. Of course, rejection or their reluctance opens the door for other publishers (including journals). “Most research journals tell you up front that, by submitting a paper, you are representing that it has not been submitted elsewhere. Not so for books.
How many journals should I submit to?
The golden rule of publication ethics is to never submit your draft paper to more than one journal at a time. This can easily translate into weeks or even months of waiting for an editorial team to review your paper.
How do you know if a journal is high quality?
The journal (academic publication) where the article is published says something about the quality of the article. Journals are ranked in the Journal Quality List (JQL). If the journal you used is ranked at the top of your professional field in the JQL, then you can assume that the quality of the article is high.
What are the other factors that may influence a researcher in deciding journal for publication?
The most important factors influencing journal choice were as follows: reliability of reviewing, usefulness of reviewers’ feedback, the reputation of the journal and confidence that their article is in scope for the journal.
What makes a journal article high quality?
The research question as well as the aim of the article should be clear and easy to understand. Have the study limitations been mentioned? The paper should mention the limitations of the study or arguments that can be made against their point to give the reader a balanced view of both sides.
How do you publish high quality research?
II. Paradigms for Publishing High-Quality Research
- Bridge Disciplines.
- Conduct a Meta-Analysis.
- Launch a Paradigm Shift: Challenge Existing Assumptions and Test Competing Theories.
- Combine Mediators and Moderators: Mediated Moderation and Moderated Mediation.
- Develop a New Tool to Assess Individual Differences.
How do you publish a high quality paper?
Here are some techniqeus and strategies you can use to ensure your work has the best chance of finding an appropriate home.
- Ask these questions before you prepare your manuscript. …
- Make your manuscript publication worthy. …
- Write a good cover letter. …
- Write an effective results section. …
- Mind your references.
How do I know if my paper is good?
A quick way to evaluate the legitimacy of a published paper is to find out about the journal in which it is published. A number of websites purport to rank journal quality or prestige, typically ascertained based on citations. Highly cited journals are thought to be better than their seldom-cited competitors.
How do you judge the quality of a study?
How to critically evaluate the quality of a research article?
- Research question. The research must be clear in informing the reader of its aims. …
- Sample. …
- Control of confounding variables. …
- Research designs. …
- Criteria and criteria measures. …
- Data analysis. …
- Discussion and conclusions. …
- Ethics.
What makes a bad research study?
Research that is in a technical sense correct, but misleading. Research that is sloppy or poorly written. Research that is made in good faith, but in error. Research that is chopped up into lots of small chunks, in terms of article length/word or page counts.
How do you know if a research article is strong?
Here are some questions you can ask yourself to determine if a study and its findings are reliable.
- What is the study saying? …
- Was it properly designed? …
- Was it peer-reviewed? …
- Is it in a quality journal? …
- Did the researchers disclose their conflicts of interest?
How do you critically evaluate a journal article?
Write a Critical Review of a Scientific Journal Article
- Start Here.
- Analyzing the Text. Identify how and why the research was carried out. Establish the research context. Evaluate the research. Establish the significance of the research.
- Writing Your Critique.
Who has published the most scientific papers?
Materials scientist Akihisa Inoue, former president of Tohoku University in Japan and a member of multiple prestigious academies, holds the record. He met our definition of being hyperprolific for 12 calendar years between . Since 1976, his name appears on 2,566 full papers indexed in Scopus.
What is the most prestigious scientific journal?
List of Top 100 Journals with Highest Impact Factor
| Rank | Journal Publication | Journal Home page |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | Nature – Impact Factor: 42.78 | View |
| 2. | The New England Journal of Medicine – Impact Factor: 74.7 | View |
| 3. | Science – Impact Factor: 41.84 | View |
| 4. | IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition – Impact Factor: 45.17 | View |
How many papers does the average professor publish?
The successful young professors published a lot.
On average, they published 25 conference papers during their first four years. The non-successful professors published only 10. (Recall, in computer science, it’s competitive conference publications, not journal publications, that matter.)
How many papers should you publish during your PhD?
While there is no hard-and-fast, field-independent rule for how many publications you should publish in grad school, some departments waive the requirement to write a dissertation if a candidate has published three peer reviewed articles. I therefore dutifully submitted three first-author manuscripts during my PhD.
What is higher than a PhD?
The Doctor of Divinity (DDiv) and the Doctor of Civil Law (DCL) are considered by Oxford to outrank all other degrees, including a Doctor of Medicine (MD) degree. The DDiv is usually awarded for academic accomplishments beyond the PhD level.
What is a good h index for a PhD student?
What is a good h-index for a Phd student? It is very common that supervisors expect up to three publications from PhD students. Given the lengthy process of publication and the fact that once the papers are out they also need to be cited, having an h-index of 1 or 2 at the end of your PhD is a big achievement.